summaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
diff options
context:
space:
mode:
-rw-r--r--meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt82
-rw-r--r--meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt.asc19
2 files changed, 101 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt b/meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..30222ad
--- /dev/null
+++ b/meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,82 @@
+
+
+Summary of the Gentoo Council meeting 25 October 2015
+
+Roll call
+=================
+Present:
+blueness, dilfridge, jlec, k_f, rich0, ulm, williamh
+
+
+1. Projects, herds, etc. [1,2,3,4]
+=================
+
+[1] https://archives.gentoo.org/gentoo-project/message/179d5d298333dfeef45a6eb78f0d6f17
+[2] https://archives.gentoo.org/gentoo-project/message/70451197c3109e61ddd27e14a7bf89fa
+[3] https://archives.gentoo.org/gentoo-project/message/3cf270a336636b94187b2a2b8f1b7e7f
+[4] https://archives.gentoo.org/gentoo-project/message/f595f9fef4bce02c875e980ec5d21841
+
+A lengthy discussion on the merits of deprecating herds and on how to
+precisely do that resulted. The suggestion to use GUIDs for project
+identification was dismissed as slightly impractical, even though they
+provide for a near-unlimited number of projects.
+
+Vote A:
+The concept of "herds" is abandoned, and the usage of the term
+deprecated. As a replacement, a package may be maintained by a
+project.
+7 yes, unanimous
+
+Vote B: do we want
+ a) "<project>bla</project>" or
+ b) "<maintainer><project>bla</project></maintainer>" or
+ c) "<maintainer type="project">bla</maintainer>" or
+ d) "<maintainer><email>bla@gentoo.org</email></maintainer>" ?
+3x a, 2x c, 2x d
+
+This led to a discussion on the meaning of the vote outcome, and it
+was decided to re-formulate the question into several votes.
+
+Vote C: New <project> tag, or add something to existing <maintainer>
+tag?
+4x project and 3x maintainer
+
+Vote D: what goes into the <project> tag? a project shortname or an
+e-mail address?
+4x shortname, 1x e-mail, 2x abstain
+
+Vote E: do we want a 1:1 mapping of a new e-mail address to the
+project shortname?
+4 yes, 2 no
+
+Vote F: define the project shortname on the wiki project page, and
+expect that any project is *also* reachable as
+shortname@proj.gentoo.org
+4 yes, 2 abstain
+
+After these decisions several council members stated that things were
+going the wrong way and that they would like to change their votes for
+earlier decisions, thereby making latter decisions obsolete. As a
+consequence, it was suggested to scrap the just-made decisions again
+and request a GLEP on the issue.
+
+Vote: "All votes today from B on are anulled. The council recommends
+that the details on herds to projects transition should be worked out
+in a GLEP."
+6 yes, 1 abstain
+
+
+2. Open bugs with council participation
+=================
+
+https://bugs.gentoo.org/503382 "Missing summaries for 20131210,
+20140114, and 20140225 council meetings"
+
+Ulm stated that the 20131210 summary has been written and submitted,
+and minor corrections were suggested.
+
+
+3. Open floor
+=================
+
+No issues were brought up.
diff --git a/meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt.asc b/meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt.asc
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..1007ad6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/meeting-logs/20151025-summary.txt.asc
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
+Version: GnuPG v2
+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+=QcbA
+-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----